It wasn’t that long ago that there were really only two options when choosing a Memory Foam mattress- Tempurpedic or the “other guy”. For a full decade, Tempurpedic dominated the mattress scene much like Tiger Woods on the golf course. No other company was able to create a feel and story that was compelling enough to turn the heads of consumers and sales professionals alike.
But recently, Simmons Beautyrest has re-launched the Comforpedic collection, and many consumers have started to take notice.
So how do these products compare? Which one is right for you?
Both Tempurpedic and Simmons Comforpedic are rated an A+ on the BBB web site. This means that they are members of the BBB and are usually excellent at handling complaints until both parties are satisfied. It DOES NOT mean that they never get complaints.
Almost all products that use foam as a component will ship with some degree of odor or off gassing. Most products manufactured in the US are required to meet a bevy of laws regarding chemicals and their use, and since Tempurpedic and Comforpedic are made in the US of US made components, both are relatively safe for use. One consumer site called sleeplikethedead.com rates Comforpedic significantly better with odor than Tempurpedic, based on consumer complaints, with Comforpedic receiving a C + rating and Tempurpedic receiving a D +. Also, Comforpedic is rated as a Certipur-US® Certified manufacturer, meaning it uses only materials that are independently verified as safe for your body and the environment.
Tempurpedic advertises that over 90% of Tempurpedic users are satisfied with their purchase, which seems impressive. But on sleeplikethedead.com, the rating is closer to 81% satisfaction. At 81%, Tempurpedic is still one of the highest rated brands. Comforpedic, however, is rated at an 84% approval and is the 2nd highest rated brand. The biggest drawback for both products seems to be price point and weight. Tempurpedic’s new Simplicity™ line starts their collection below $1500 for a queen mattress, but does not include any real memory foam and only has a 10 yr warranty. Comforpedic’s collection starts around the same price point, but uses a full 1.5” sheet of memory foam and has a 25 yr limited warranty, making Comforpedic a better value proposition.
Related Links worth Looking at!
More Reviews on Tempurpedic Memory Foam
Comforpedic Memory Foam Mattress Demonstration – Watch this Video